Journal Article

Deciding who and what to trust
1/1

Deciding Who & What to Trust: Recognising the Red, Orange & Green Flags

By Amelia Kruse | December 5, 2024 | 6 min read

Trust is a choice. But how we choose is often flawed.

In an ideal world, deciding who and what to trust would happen by considering all the red, orange, and green flags and actually following through on what you discover. You would spend time bringing awareness to your observations, beliefs, feelings, intuitions, experiences, values and fears and actively decide whether to lean into (or out of) an experience or relationship.

However, in reality, deciding who and what to trust is often a flawed process. Some of us tend to trust too easily, surrendering to vulnerability without sufficient discernment (me!). Others lean reflexively into distrust, closing themselves off. And some get stuck in endless analysis, unable to take the leap of faith. None of these extremes are ideal – they can either expose us to harm or prevent us from having meaningful connections and experiences.

So what is the balanced approach? Navigating trust requires both diligent discernment and the courage to surrender to uncertainty. We can never be certain where our choices will lead, so we must learn to trust ourselves – our awareness, our judgment, our commitment to the path. This self-trust, which I call ‘The Foundation’, underpins our ability to recognize the red, orange, and green flags and make authentic, effective decisions.

The Due Diligence

Trust

If you’re one of those people who either likes to dive right in or to close yourself off without doing much reflection and discernment, this step is most important for you. It’s usually not that you don’t have the abilities to think it through, challenge your assumptions and be introspective, it’s probably because you just don’t really have the time or, the default behaviour of diving right in or shutting yourself off is so strong you may not even realise you’re doing it.

To start unlearning these habits you first need to see the benefits of creating space for some due diligence. And there’s no better way of doing that than by experimenting with it. Use the following questions as a blueprint and run through them with either a past or current scenario and see if it helps you uncover some important red, green or orange flags.

1. Observations

  • What specific behaviors or patterns have I noticed in this person or situation?
  • Has there been demonstrations of consistency, empathy, and integrity?
  • Are there clear signs of ‘red lag’ behaviours for example control, secrecy, or lack of accountability?

2. Beliefs

  • What core beliefs do I hold that might be affecting my perspective of this person or experience?
  • What beliefs am I starting to hold about this person or experience and are these beliefs rooted in facts or are they assumptions?

3. Feelings

  • How do I feel when I’m around this person or engaged in this experience?
  • Do I feel comfortable being myself

4. Intuitions

  • What is my gut telling me about this situation or person?
  • Do I sense anything off or out of alignment, even if I can’t articulate why?

5. Experiences

  • What previous interactions or situations are shaping my perspective currently? Am I projecting past situations onto this one that is affecting my judgment?
  • Have there been misunderstandings or missteps that the person is willing to address and learn from?

6. Values

  • What are my core values and does this person or experience align with them?
  • Do I value what this person or experience enough for the potential risks involved in leaning in?
  • Are there differences in values or priorities that may require deeper conversation?

7. Fears

  • What fears or insecurities might be influencing my judgment in this situation?
  • Are these fears based on this current situation, or are they echoes of the past?
  • Could my fear of loss or conflict be causing me to overlook potential red flags?

if there are gaps in knowledge or questions you couldn’t answer, seek to gain more insight through asking other people for their insights and/or making it a point to continue to gather the data yourself.

Due diligence is not just important to do upfront in deciding to lean into or out of an experience or relationship but it’s also crucial as you move through experiences and build relationships so that you can continuously decide to keep committed to the path or shift directions.

The Surrendering

After the due diligence, the next step is surrendering – deciding on a path and taking action, even in the face of uncertainty. This involves asking yourself questions like the following:

  • Given the insights from the due diligence, is it best to lean in to or lean out of this experience or relationship?
  • What would it look like to either lean in or lean out in this specific scenario? What are my options?
  • What support do I need or want to take action, be vulnerable and step into uncertainty?

As with due diligence, surrendering isn’t a one and done scenario. You’ll likely need to recommit to the path regularly, until it becomes more natural and less of a conscious act. This requires courage. If you ever falter, revisit your due diligence insights and recommit to the chosen path with courage and growing conviction.

The Foundations

The ability to trust yourself and the process is the essential foundation for navigating trust decisions. Without this, you’ll likely undermine your journey at every turn. Building self-trust involves cultivating a strong, dependable relationship with yourself, grounded in self-awareness, self-respect, and consistent actions.

To build the foundations of trust, we need to have consistent practices that reframe our beliefs and shift our mindset. Here are some questions to ask yourself to create some core practices:

  • What do I value and how do I or could I live these values?
  • What limiting beliefs do I hold and how could I turn them into empowering beliefs?
  • How can I nurture a growth mindset and reframe challenges as opportunities for growth?
  • How can I celebrate or at least acknowledge wins and achievements in a stabilising way?
  • How can I support myself to honour the commitments I make to myself?
  • How can I gather data/evidence in my day-to-day life that shows I can rely on myself and the process?

Deciding who and what to trust is an ongoing process of balancing discernment and vulnerability. By cultivating self-trust as the foundation, we empower ourselves to navigate the red, orange, and green flags with clarity and authenticity. With practice, this becomes an invaluable skill that helps us live an authentic and fulfilling life and manage the challenges and uncertainties along the way.


Amelia Kruse is the founder of Sageform, a conscious leadership studio, and creator of the Sageform Method°, a framework for creatives, leaders, and founders ready to lead from the inside out. You can learn more about working together here.

Words

  • Written by: Amelia Kruse

Share